The Rowling Record

J.K. Rowling’s trans-related posts from 2024

Page 4 of 12. Posts 301–400 of the 1,194 J.K. Rowling wrote about trans people in 2024, newest first.

22 September 2024 to 19 October 2024. Posts are reproduced in full from the archive; the stance, intensity and topic labels come from the research classifications. How the labels are defined. Search within 2024.

Classified mocking · Intensity 3/4 · Language & definitions, Sport

Classified mocking · Intensity 3/4 · Language & definitions, Specific individuals

J.K. RowlingJ.K. Rowling@jk_rowling

Women aren't 'reduced' by recognition of the fact that we're the sex whose bodies are organised to produce children. Only those who feel there's something lesser about the female reproductive system (or who haven't got one but wish they did) assert that it somehow diminishes us. https://t.co/ywSSG98Xab

381 replies2,056 retweets15,920 likes

Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Language & definitions

J.K. RowlingJ.K. Rowling@jk_rowling

'Some women trust trans-identified men' is a remix of 'not all men'. All available evidence shows there are ENOUGH predatory men, trans-identifying or not, to make safeguarding necessary if you value the security of women and girls. This isn't 'trusting my gut.' It's fact. https://t.co/FhVVXEzRLO

279 replies1,414 retweets9,874 likes

Classified critical · Intensity 3/4 · Single-sex spaces, Child safeguarding

J.K. RowlingJ.K. Rowling@jk_rowling

Trans activism demands that women give away their hard won rights to men. It requires women to sacrifice their own safety and privacy. It redefines females as a subset of their own sex class. It wants women to accept lies and unfalsifiable claims. It tells women this is 'kind.' https://t.co/NozuPKG0lr

717 replies5,109 retweets29,563 likes

Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Single-sex spaces, Language & definitions, Free speech & cancellation

Classified mocking · Intensity 3/4 · Single-sex spaces, Language & definitions

Classified critical · Intensity 3/4 · Single-sex spaces, Law & gender recognition, Language & definitions, Child safeguarding

Classified mocking · Intensity 3/4 · Language & definitions

Classified mocking · Intensity 3/4 · Language & definitions, Single-sex spaces

Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Single-sex spaces, Language & definitions, Child safeguarding

Classified mocking · Intensity 2/4 · Specific individuals, Other

Classified mocking · Intensity 3/4 · Language & definitions, Free speech & cancellation, Specific individuals

Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Single-sex spaces

J.K. RowlingJ.K. Rowling@jk_rowling

Replying to @jk_rowling

How much more physical, emotional and mental harm will have to be done to women and girls, especially the most vulnerable, before gender ideologues like Sandy Brindley admit all they've achieved is furthering men's rights at the expense of those they can't define? 12/X

61 replies462 retweets4,666 likes

Classified hostile · Intensity 3/4 · Single-sex spaces, Child safeguarding, Specific individuals, Language & definitions

Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Specific individuals, Child safeguarding

Classified critical · Intensity 3/4 · Child safeguarding, Single-sex spaces, Specific individuals

J.K. RowlingJ.K. Rowling@jk_rowling

Replying to @jk_rowling

One direct consequence of Brindley's ideological stance is that rape survivors have self-excluded from the Edinburgh centre, because of the toxic culture flourishing there. In 2022, a group of survivors tried to raise their concerns with Brindley at a meeting. 8/12

19 replies226 retweets3,403 likes

Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Single-sex spaces, Specific individuals, Media & institutions

J.K. RowlingJ.K. Rowling@jk_rowling

Replying to @jk_rowling

We've already seen ample evidence of what happens when this ideology is imposed on institutions: sportswomen placed in serious physical danger, female prisoners incarcerated with rapists, girls' honours taken by boys, predatory men taking full advantage of new conditions. 7/12

9 replies251 retweets3,585 likes

Classified hostile · Intensity 3/4 · Sport, Single-sex spaces, Child safeguarding, Language & definitions

Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Single-sex spaces, Sport, Adult healthcare, Law & gender recognition, Language & definitions

J.K. RowlingJ.K. Rowling@jk_rowling

Replying to @jk_rowling

Brindley and Wadhwa appear to have agreed that it is 'progressive' to pretend gender identity should supersede sex as the measure of what a woman is. This is in spite of the fact that 98% of sexual offenders are male (irrespective of how they identify) and 88% female. 5/12

42 replies235 retweets3,277 likes

Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Single-sex spaces, Language & definitions, Child safeguarding

Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Single-sex spaces, Child safeguarding, Specific individuals, Media & institutions

J.K. RowlingJ.K. Rowling@jk_rowling

Replying to @jk_rowling

One year on and Brindley still hasn't produced her definition. You might think the CEO of a service that claims to offer woman-only support would be able to say what a woman is, but Brindley is one of those whose ideology forbids any definition of women that excludes men. 3/12

24 replies360 retweets4,193 likes

Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Language & definitions, Single-sex spaces, Specific individuals

Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Single-sex spaces, Language & definitions, Media & institutions

Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Single-sex spaces, Child safeguarding, Media & institutions, Specific individuals

Classified mocking · Intensity 3/4 · Specific individuals, Language & definitions, Free speech & cancellation

Classified neutral · Intensity 0/4 · Media & institutions

J.K. RowlingJ.K. Rowling@jk_rowling

Did any of those releasing insects in an attempt to sabotage the @AllianceLGB conference have a split second of sanity in which they thought 'Am I in fact proving every critic of gender identity ideology right? Is trying to disrupt a meeting of gay people a tad homophobic?'

665 replies2,425 retweets19,709 likes

Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Free speech & cancellation, Media & institutions

J.K. RowlingJ.K. Rowling@jk_rowling

Replying to @cyberfrontier

@cyberfrontier Old school transsexuals existed since long before the rise of gender identity ideology and failing to recognise the diversity within the trans-identified community makes any accurate analysis of what's going on, especially for young people, next to impossible. I know trans people who believe in the reality and immutability of human sex and who support sex-based rights. Some have shared their complex and sometimes traumatic histories with me. Dismissing everyone who self-identifies as trans as 'cult members' takes us precisely nowhere.

175 replies182 retweets3,087 likes

Classified critical · Intensity 1/4 · Language & definitions, Youth healthcare, Specific individuals, Other

J.K. RowlingJ.K. Rowling@jk_rowling

I say the following again because, while I understand people's strong views on the matter, some of the language policing is getting a bit wearing. As I've said multiple times, I do not believe that a person can be born in the wrong body and I don't believe in gendered brains or souls. I believe the ideology that preaches such ideas is dangerous. However, there are people in this world who want to present as the opposite sex for many diverse reasons - some of which I'm truly sympathetic to, others far less so - all of whom call themselves 'trans.' I use the word 'trans' in the full awareness that this umbrella term covers multiple groups who have nothing else in common with each other, such as straight men who enjoy cross-dressing for erotic purposes and young lesbians who, tragically, feel they'll be happier without their breasts. When I talk about sex-based rights, I use the word 'trans' to denote 'people who wish to be seen or treated as the opposite sex', no more or less. Telling me ad nauseam that 'there is no such thing as a trans person' isn't overly helpful, because you're trying to pull me into a different argument, on which I've already made my position clear.

Read the full post
1,162 replies3,381 retweets40,310 likes

Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Language & definitions, Youth healthcare, Single-sex spaces, Free speech & cancellation

Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Single-sex spaces, Specific individuals, Language & definitions

J.K. RowlingJ.K. Rowling@jk_rowling

Replying to @adammcarter

@adammcarter We're living through a cultural moment about which future humans will say 'how the actual fuck could anyone have thought that was OK?' And we'll have archives demonstrating how people not merely failed to notice or speak up, but went out of their way to justify and encourage it.

67 replies412 retweets2,715 likes

Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Child safeguarding, Youth healthcare, Media & institutions

Classified defensive · Intensity 1/4 · Specific individuals, Media & institutions

Classified hostile · Intensity 3/4 · Specific individuals, Other

Classified mocking · Intensity 3/4 · Specific individuals, Language & definitions

Classified critical · Intensity 1/4 · Single-sex spaces

J.K. RowlingJ.K. Rowling@jk_rowling

Does Butlins think the desire of cross-dressing men to enter women-only spaces is more important than women's and girls' right to privacy and dignity? Hopefully Butlins will explain their policy, so women and families can make an informed choice about where to go on holiday.

884 replies4,337 retweets24,261 likes

Classified hostile · Intensity 3/4 · Single-sex spaces

J.K. RowlingJ.K. Rowling@jk_rowling

The only reason you think sex-testing is discriminatory is that you think male athletes should be able to hide their sex when competing against women, and if you think a cheek swab, which is all that's required, is 'violent', you're too delusional to be allowed out on your own. https://t.co/Y3jmUaWeIr

609 replies5,012 retweets32,440 likes

Classified critical · Intensity 3/4 · Sport, Single-sex spaces

Classified hostile · Intensity 3/4 · Single-sex spaces, Language & definitions

Classified critical · Intensity 1/4 · Other

Classified hostile · Intensity 3/4 · Language & definitions, Single-sex spaces

Classified critical · Intensity 3/4 · Single-sex spaces, Language & definitions

Classified mocking · Intensity 3/4 · Specific individuals

Classified mocking · Intensity 3/4 · Specific individuals

Classified hostile · Intensity 3/4 · Specific individuals, Language & definitions

Classified critical · Intensity 3/4 · Youth healthcare, Single-sex spaces, Child safeguarding, Language & definitions

J.K. RowlingJ.K. Rowling@jk_rowling

Trans people already have full rights and legal protections in this country, so why should society at large adopt an ideology that not only has 'holes in it', but far-reaching repercussions for freedom of speech, safeguarding of minors, and women's and girls' rights? https://t.co/bEeAz2QySN

411 replies2,570 retweets21,396 likes

Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Free speech & cancellation, Child safeguarding, Single-sex spaces, Language & definitions

Classified mocking · Intensity 2/4 · Language & definitions

Classified critical · Intensity 3/4 · Single-sex spaces, Child safeguarding, Language & definitions

Classified critical · Intensity 1/4 · Language & definitions

J.K. RowlingJ.K. Rowling@jk_rowling

Unlike sex, gender identity is neither scientifically observable nor testable. In spite of the million word salads attempting one, there's no stable definition of gender identity. The term is variously but not exclusively applied to an innate certainty that one is not the sex one was born, to a constantly shifting sense of self that may be male, female, neither or both, to the extent to which one identifies with often regressive sex stereotypes, or to something akin to a gendered soul, which may be trapped in the 'wrong' body. Gender identity is an unfalsifiable idea, a socio-political construct, a quasi-religious belief. At bottom, it is defined by little more than a person's subjective feelings, or (more accurately) their claim to feel those feelings. We are told we must believe in the existence of those feelings and that those feelings constitute a new form of fact, even though in literally no other sphere of human life is it held that a person's self-perception must be accepted unquestioningly as true or real. Gender identity ideology is doing measurable, serious harm to some very vulnerable young people and to women. We're watching a medical scandal of terrifying proportions unfold in front of us, along with an assault on the rights of women and girls in the developed world that is unparalleled in my lifetime. I've read treatises on astrology that make more sense than the spiel written on gender identity and I believe that those who continue to push gender identity as 'real' or scientifically observable are guilty of causing widespread damage. The effects are being felt not only by vulnerable individuals, but in once-impartial and rational disciplines and institutions, which, like you, have embraced a form of faith-based fundamentalism masquerading as intellectual sophistication.

Read the full post
1,701 replies6,295 retweets35,531 likes

Classified critical · Intensity 3/4 · Language & definitions, Youth healthcare, Single-sex spaces, Child safeguarding, Media & institutions

J.K. RowlingJ.K. Rowling@jk_rowling

If you take descriptive adjectives such as 'black' or 'gay' away from the word woman, 'woman' continues to carry its usual meaning, ie, adult human female. 'Trans woman' is a compound noun, with a space or not. Take away 'trans' and, by definition, you've got a man. https://t.co/QtmPteKiOd

765 replies2,433 retweets19,024 likes

Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Language & definitions

Classified hostile · Intensity 3/4 · Language & definitions, Single-sex spaces

Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Single-sex spaces, Child safeguarding, Language & definitions

Classified critical · Intensity 1/4 · Single-sex spaces, Child safeguarding

Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Single-sex spaces, Child safeguarding

Classified hostile · Intensity 3/4 · Single-sex spaces, Child safeguarding

Classified mocking · Intensity 3/4 · Language & definitions

Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Single-sex spaces, Child safeguarding, Adult healthcare, Media & institutions

Classified mocking · Intensity 3/4 · Single-sex spaces, Child safeguarding

Classified mocking · Intensity 3/4 · Specific individuals, Language & definitions

Classified mocking · Intensity 3/4 · Language & definitions, Free speech & cancellation

Classified critical · Intensity 1/4 · Free speech & cancellation, Media & institutions

Classified mocking · Intensity 2/4 · Language & definitions

J.K. RowlingJ.K. Rowling@jk_rowling

Replying to @sleeepysandy

@sleeepysandy What do you think continues to infuriate him, five years after her death, about a brilliant, witty feminist lesbian who stood against creepy heterosexual men who don't think teenage girls should be allowed a penis-free space in which to shower? Guess we'll never know.

103 replies349 retweets4,372 likes

Classified hostile · Intensity 3/4 · Single-sex spaces, Child safeguarding, Specific individuals

Classified critical · Intensity 1/4 · Law & gender recognition, Language & definitions

Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Language & definitions, Free speech & cancellation, Law & gender recognition

Classified mocking · Intensity 2/4 · Language & definitions, Single-sex spaces

Classified mocking · Intensity 2/4 · Single-sex spaces, Specific individuals

Classified defensive · Intensity 1/4 · Specific individuals, Free speech & cancellation

Classified critical · Intensity 1/4 · Media & institutions, Language & definitions

Classified critical · Intensity 1/4 · Language & definitions, Specific individuals

Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Single-sex spaces, Law & gender recognition, Specific individuals

J.K. RowlingJ.K. Rowling@jk_rowling

@alison_stewart5 Never, ever, ever. Only depraved bigots could imagine that men arguing for the removal of safeguarding for women and girls have any motive other than a desire to see a fairer, more just and tolerant world. Honestly, it makes me weep to think of their selflessness.

22 replies100 retweets1,769 likes

Classified mocking · Intensity 3/4 · Single-sex spaces, Child safeguarding, Free speech & cancellation

J.K. RowlingJ.K. Rowling@jk_rowling

The important thing to remember is, he's a total one off*, none of the other men arguing against women-only spaces are predators** and we won't find out down the line there are more rapists hiding in plain sight.*** *He really isn't. **They totally are. ***We definitely will. https://t.co/VW7jYb92zW

893 replies7,476 retweets45,478 likes

Classified hostile · Intensity 3/4 · Single-sex spaces, Child safeguarding

Classified mocking · Intensity 1/4 · Language & definitions, Media & institutions

J.K. RowlingJ.K. Rowling@jk_rowling

Rosie Duffield was one of the few female Labour politicians with the guts to stand up for vulnerable women and girls, while self-satisfied numbskulls like you fought to give away their rights and spaces. TL;DR Keep her name out of your mouth.

742 replies4,843 retweets33,207 likes

Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Single-sex spaces, Specific individuals, Media & institutions

Classified neutral · Intensity 0/4 · Specific individuals, Adult healthcare

Classified hostile · Intensity 3/4 · Child safeguarding, Single-sex spaces, Specific individuals

J.K. RowlingJ.K. Rowling@jk_rowling

He never stopped being a man. He has always been a member of the sex that commits 98% of all sexual crimes. He also belongs to the subset of men who claim they're women, but offend at exactly the same rate as those who don't.

516 replies4,362 retweets36,615 likes

Classified hostile · Intensity 4/4 · Child safeguarding, Single-sex spaces, Specific individuals, Language & definitions

J.K. RowlingJ.K. Rowling@jk_rowling

Chief Constable Jo Farrell explains why letting rapists identify as women wasn't misogynistic. Great news for all Scottish women and girls gaslit, triggered and re-traumatised by Police Scotland telling them some women have penises they stick in other women without consent. https://t.co/QRE10uTMhy

334 replies1,728 retweets10,877 likes

Classified hostile · Intensity 4/4 · Single-sex spaces, Child safeguarding, Language & definitions, Specific individuals, Media & institutions

Classified mocking · Intensity 3/4 · Specific individuals

Classified mocking · Intensity 3/4 · Specific individuals

Classified mocking · Intensity 3/4 · Specific individuals, Language & definitions

J.K. RowlingJ.K. Rowling@jk_rowling

Replying to @bindelj

@bindelj This is literal violence/pure hate/outright bigotry/triggering my CPSD/literally what the Nazis did/the end of our friendship/making me literally shake and vomit/an opportunity to remind people to contribute to my Crowdfunder for a third leg* *delete as appropriate

14 replies20 retweets421 likes

Classified mocking · Intensity 2/4 · Free speech & cancellation, Media & institutions

Classified critical · Intensity 1/4 · Single-sex spaces, Specific individuals, Media & institutions

Classified mocking · Intensity 1/4 · Free speech & cancellation, Language & definitions

Classified mocking · Intensity 3/4 · Specific individuals

Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Language & definitions, Free speech & cancellation

Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Single-sex spaces, Specific individuals, Language & definitions

Classified mocking · Intensity 2/4 · Language & definitions, Other

Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Specific individuals, Language & definitions

Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Specific individuals, Language & definitions

J.K. RowlingJ.K. Rowling@jk_rowling

Replying to @wjconville

@wjconville @MoniFunGirl With respect, I'll talk to whoever I want and I'll say what I want to say to them however I want to say it. There are people in this world who want to be perceived - for many diverse reasons - as the opposite sex. Such people are commonly called 'trans'. I've made it clear countless times that I don't believe we all have a gendered essence that may turn up in the wrong body and many trans people (in the sense in which I've used the word) agree with me. To assume a person you don't know has a 'dangerous split personality' is offensive . You know nothing about the person with whom I was talking, nothing about their inner life or their struggles. They were nothing but polite, respectful and empathetic so I find your reaction strange, to say the least.

14 replies11 retweets236 likes

Classified critical · Intensity 1/4 · Language & definitions, Specific individuals

Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Sport, Single-sex spaces, Specific individuals

Classified defensive · Intensity 0/4 · Single-sex spaces, Child safeguarding

Classified critical · Intensity 1/4 · Free speech & cancellation

J.K. RowlingJ.K. Rowling@jk_rowling

No, that's one thing Brindley and I agree on: I want her fired. If the board had any sense at all they'd realise that offering rape survivors' phone numbers to a journalist is as bad as it gets. They're already complicit in the Edinburgh centre calamity. Time to grow a spine. https://t.co/aMXxogY2OI

180 replies1,903 retweets13,319 likes

Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Single-sex spaces, Specific individuals, Media & institutions, Child safeguarding

Classified critical · Intensity 1/4 · Single-sex spaces, Language & definitions

Classified critical · Intensity 1/4 · Single-sex spaces, Language & definitions

J.K. RowlingJ.K. Rowling@jk_rowling

The point is that those women were and are extremely important - the most important of all. Rape Crisis Scotland's entire purpose was to serve those women, but she dismissed their views as of no consequence. She addresses me only to claim victimhood. You're right. It's textbook. https://t.co/2ystr6FTaz

123 replies1,123 retweets10,107 likes

Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Single-sex spaces, Media & institutions

These are the posts classified trans-related. Search all 16,714 collected tweets, read the year-by-year analysis, or read the report on her campaign against trans rights.