@JNHanvey @HumzaYousaf Thank you, Neale. You’re one of the very few Scottish politicians to show me any solidarity regarding this constant harassment and I truly appreciate it.
16 January 2024 to 21 March 2024. Posts are reproduced in full from the archive; the stance, intensity and topic labels come from the research classifications. How the labels are defined. Search within 2024.
Classified defensive · Intensity 1/4 · Free speech & cancellation, Specific individuals
You’re painting a target on people who have no connection with me, who aren’t my relatives. You surely know what you’re doing, but persist. Hate me all you like, but your actions are having real world consequences for people I don’t even know.
Classified defensive · Intensity 1/4 · Free speech & cancellation, Specific individuals
@NotScottNewgent @wizardingnews Thank you, Scott 😘
Classified neutral · Intensity 0/4 · Specific individuals
Classified neutral · Intensity 0/4 · Free speech & cancellation, Specific individuals, Media & institutions
The number of people who feel compelled to tell me that if they had my money they wouldn’t give a damn about the rights of women and children never ceases to amaze me. I believe you, of course, I’m just surprised that’s something you like to boast about.
Classified defensive · Intensity 1/4 · Child safeguarding, Single-sex spaces, Free speech & cancellation
Let's compare what each of us has got over the past five years, @IndiaWilloughby, and see who's had the greatest number of threats of murder, torture, burning, skinning, rape (in every possible mutation) and assault (again, in every possible variation) from the other's allies. https://t.co/nluARy8j8W
Classified defensive · Intensity 2/4 · Specific individuals, Free speech & cancellation
Replying to @damekatydenise_
@damekatydenise_ The truly inclusive say ‘gestational mechanism’. Bigot.
Classified mocking · Intensity 2/4 · Language & definitions
@ProfChalmers @michaelpforan Guess I’ll just have to do some more accurate sexing post-April 1st and we’ll see whether my previous offences are taken into account.
Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Law & gender recognition, Language & definitions
‘I am a man who wants to see girls and women stripped of their rights and protections for the benefit of my fellow men. I know this makes me a really good guy and other guys I know agree with me. I am proud of being such a great guy.’ https://t.co/qao5Xp2r6z
Classified hostile · Intensity 3/4 · Single-sex spaces, Language & definitions
If you genuinely imagine I’d delete posts calling a man a man, so as not to be prosecuted under this ludicrous law, stand by for the mother of all April Fools’ jokes. https://t.co/ZVZQ6CV47p
Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Law & gender recognition, Free speech & cancellation, Language & definitions
‘…the Scottish government has contrived to create a bill which affords greater status and protection to men who cross-dress than it does to actual women.’ ✍️ Alex Massie https://t.co/NyR2QeZRKs
Classified critical · Intensity 3/4 · Law & gender recognition, Single-sex spaces
Replying to @therunninggrave
@therunninggrave @damekatydenise_ @WRNGuernsey The mask is constantly coming off. I appear to be wearing about eight hundred masks. Not a day passes when the mask isn't declared to be FULLY OFF NOW.
Classified defensive · Intensity 0/4 · Specific individuals, Free speech & cancellation
Replying to @LauraGr31918310
@LauraGr31918310 @CriticalCupcake There's no point with that one. I've never known them able to back up a single bonkers claim. It's like trying to locate matter inside a black hole.
Classified mocking · Intensity 2/4 · Free speech & cancellation
‘This repellent experiment… belongs in the book of medical disgraces. As do the cheerleaders who raised money for Mermaids and those who persecuted whistleblowers or damned journalists asking questions as transphobic.’ ✍️ Janice Turner https://t.co/OhNgr7mWIu
Classified critical · Intensity 3/4 · Youth healthcare, Child safeguarding, Media & institutions, Free speech & cancellation
‘Are Scottish children different from English ones? If the Tavistock gender clinic is not fit for purpose, how can the Sandyford clinic be safe when it operates on precisely the same principles as the now discredited Tavistock one?’ ✍️ Alex Massie https://t.co/yyDWaRB5cp
Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Youth healthcare, Child safeguarding, Media & institutions
Replying to @Esqueer_
@Esqueer_ The thread has sources. Please show your evidence that trans-identifying people were persecuted, as distinct from gay people, who were indeed victims of heinous treatment by the Nazis.
Classified critical · Intensity 1/4 · Specific individuals, Language & definitions
Replying to @_RogueGhost_
@figar0h I know all about Hischfield. Are you sure you want to make him a poster boy for trans medicine? The man who believed in sterilisation of the unfit?
Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Adult healthcare, Media & institutions, Specific individuals
Thread on the persistent claims about trans people and the Nazis 👇
Classified critical · Intensity 1/4 · Adult healthcare, Media & institutions, Other
Replying to @Esqueer_
@Esqueer_ Neither of your articles support the contention that trans people were the first victims of the Nazis or that all research on trans healthcare was burned in 1930s Germany. You are engaging in lying, Alejandra.
Classified critical · Intensity 1/4 · Media & institutions, Specific individuals
I heard there was a bit in Revelation about puberty blockers, but Leviticus made them take it out. https://t.co/ffqMG5PutI
Classified critical · Intensity 1/4 · Youth healthcare
Don’t forget the abject cowardice of many politicians, sections of the press and certain members of the medical profession, all of whom allowed themselves to be intimidated by a loud, angry mob that capitalised on their fear of not looking progressive and sophisticated enough. https://t.co/EshJL63JcD
Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Youth healthcare, Media & institutions, Free speech & cancellation
Read the WPATH files. Medics acknowledged children weren’t capable of giving informed consent but kept on operating and prescribing. Prison terms for doctors experimenting on troubled minors are more than fine with me. https://t.co/4sqV5BIBRW
Classified critical · Intensity 3/4 · Youth healthcare, Child safeguarding, Media & institutions
Stonewall’s pernicious influence on public policy, the clear conflict of interest in taking money from the bodies it’s lobbying and its irresponsible dissemination of medical misinformation have gone on far too long. https://t.co/VoFn3OzyBm
Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Media & institutions, Youth healthcare, Free speech & cancellation
Replying to @RedWallPleb
@RedWallPleb Joint first place with Mermaids.
Classified hostile · Intensity 3/4 · Specific individuals, Media & institutions, Child safeguarding
“Experiments have been conducted on the bodies of children due to the political cowardice of adults.” ✍️ Victoria Smith
Classified critical · Intensity 3/4 · Youth healthcare, Child safeguarding
Replying to @Weeto_boy
@Weeto_boy @WyrdGrl @helenstaniland @RooneyRachel @AmitChampaneri1 This is from 2024. Are these side effects common with the contraceptive pill? https://t.co/oY7gLJR9Oz
Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Youth healthcare, Adult healthcare
Replying to @Weeto_boy
@Weeto_boy @helenstaniland @RooneyRachel @AmitChampaneri1 Where's your evidence that these drugs are no different to the contraceptive pill? I'd like to read it, because my understanding is that they're many times more powerful, cause long term damage and are no longer in 'commonplace' use to treat precocious puberty, for that reason.
Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Youth healthcare
The evidence has been out there for years, for all who were prepared to open their eyes. https://t.co/bm209jvh6e
Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Youth healthcare, Child safeguarding
Willoughby is propagating dangerous lies. Women who were put on Lupron to delay puberty have suffered long-term harm. '“It just feels like I’m being punished for basically being experimented on when I was a child,” said Derricott, of Lawton, Okla.' https://t.co/IHTYn80Uod https://t.co/1RQoIvuPEL
Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Youth healthcare, Child safeguarding, Specific individuals
Replying to @RooneyRachel
@RooneyRachel @AmitChampaneri1 Too much irreversible harm has been done for me to be happy about any of this, but the fact that certain people nailed their colours so proudly and publicly to the mast will be useful when the post-mortem finally happens. There certainly won't be any paucity of evidence.
Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Youth healthcare, Child safeguarding, Media & institutions
Replying to @jk_rowling
I'm afraid this tactic doesn't work on me. Perhaps your time would be better spent thinking up some reasons you cheered on the sterilisation of gay and autistic kids? One of your co-religionists is probably working on a slogan right now. We all look forward to seeing it. https://t.co/EUEOg5m2Bp
Classified hostile · Intensity 3/4 · Youth healthcare, Child safeguarding, Free speech & cancellation
Replying to @AmitChampaneri1
@AmitChampaneri1 Well-funded lobbying groups drunk on their own power, politicians closing their eyes rather than suffer social media pushback, idiot celeb cheerleaders who're about to go very quiet, pharmaceutical companies chasing profit, medics who abandoned ethics and should be in the dock.
Classified hostile · Intensity 3/4 · Youth healthcare, Child safeguarding, Media & institutions, Free speech & cancellation
“Given paucity of evidence, the off-label use of drugs […] in gender dysphoria treatment largely means an unregulated live experiment on children.” Professor Carl Heneghan, director of the Centre of Evidence-Based Medicine at Oxford, 2019.
Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Youth healthcare, Child safeguarding
Replying to @HazelAppleyard
@HazelAppleyard_ Tinkerbell Syndrome: the conviction that unless all women, everywhere, believe a man is a woman, he will die.
Classified mocking · Intensity 3/4 · Language & definitions, Single-sex spaces
Replying to @andisonline
@andisonline If you believe everything short of total agreement with your viewpoint and unquestioning validation of your self-image is cruelty, I fear for your ability to survive adult life.
Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Free speech & cancellation
I don’t know. You embrace ‘inclusive’ language, parrot their beliefs, and it makes them angrier than ever. 😢
Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Language & definitions, Free speech & cancellation
Devastated and bewildered that my embrace of inclusive language has angered its most enthusiastic devotees, so let's just say: Happy Mother's Day to all females who've raised children. 💐❤️
Classified mocking · Intensity 2/4 · Language & definitions
❤️💐Happy Birthing Parent Day to all whose large gametes were fertilised resulting in small humans whose sex was assigned by doctors making mostly lucky guesses ❤️💐
Classified mocking · Intensity 2/4 · Language & definitions
Someone needs to read the #WPATHfiles. Soon.
Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Youth healthcare, Law & gender recognition, Media & institutions
The word ‘transphobic’, as used here, does not mean an irrational fear or dislike of trans people. It means refusing to use gender identity ideology’s jargon, refusing to parrot its slogans, refusing to accept that sex doesn't matter when it comes to sport and single-sex spaces, refusing to believe a bearded heterosexual man becomes a lesbian when he declares himself one, and refusing to believe an abusive, misogynistic male is a woman because he likes to wear mini-dresses and pout in selfies. Like every other gender critical person I know, I believe everyone should be free to express themselves however they wish, dress however they please, call themselves whatever they want, sleep with any consenting adult who wishes to sleep with them, and that trans-identified people should have the same protections regarding employment, housing, freedom of speech and personal safety every other citizen is entitled to. But this isn’t nearly enough for the dominant strain of trans activism, which asserts that unless freedom of speech is removed from dissenters, unless trans-identified men are permitted to strip away women’s rights, with particular reference to single sex spaces like rape crisis centres, prison cells, hospital wards, changing rooms and public bathrooms, until we all bow down to their neo-religion, accept their pseudo-scientific claims and embrace their circular reasoning, trans people are more oppressed, and more at risk, than any other group in society. This is nonsense. 99.9% of the world knows it's nonsense. The emperor is naked. He might be wearing lipstick, but his balls are swinging in plain sight.
Read the full postClassified hostile · Intensity 4/4 · Single-sex spaces, Sport, Language & definitions, Free speech & cancellation, Law & gender recognition
Extraordinary. India’s interviewer calls India ‘him’ twice. The police are going to be very busy.
Classified mocking · Intensity 2/4 · Language & definitions, Specific individuals
Replying to @MsKimKaze
@MsKimKaze You're far from the only dysphoric person, including those who have transitioned, who've said exactly this to me. I'm sorry. This comes with love x
Classified critical · Intensity 1/4 · Adult healthcare, Specific individuals
Replying to @jk_rowling
Aware as I am that it's an offence to lie to law enforcement, I'll simply have to explain to the police that, in my view, India is a classic example of the male narcissist who lives in a state of perpetual rage that he can't compel women to take him at his own valuation. 5/5
Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Specific individuals, Law & gender recognition
Replying to @jk_rowling
Surprisingly for such an eminent legal authority, he appears to have forgotten that the Forstater ruling established that gender critical views can be protected in law as a philosophical belief. No law compels anyone to pretend to believe that India is a woman. 4/5
Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Law & gender recognition, Free speech & cancellation, Language & definitions
Replying to @jk_rowling
Nor have I forgotten India's shocking transphobia. It appears to have slipped what passes for India's mind that he's previously called a fellow trans woman a man on this very site. 3/5 https://t.co/Prk1ikBwLq
Classified defensive · Intensity 1/4 · Specific individuals, Language & definitions
Some time ago, lawyers advised me that not only did I have a clearly winnable case against India Willoughby for defamation, but that India's obsessive targeting of me over the past few years may meet the legal threshold for harassment. 1/5
Classified defensive · Intensity 1/4 · Specific individuals, Free speech & cancellation
"It will go down as one of the worst medical scandals in history." The #wpathfiles put it beyond doubt that surgeries and drugs of unproven benefit are being given to those who cannot give informed consent. If you're still cheering this on, you are complicit.
Classified critical · Intensity 3/4 · Youth healthcare, Adult healthcare, Child safeguarding, Media & institutions
For reference, this is the individual whose precious feelings are more important than truth, according to some of his fellow men. If you think women calling this person a man is more offensive than him publicly fantasising about kidnapping women, I can't help you. https://t.co/mrqIC8jbtL
Classified hostile · Intensity 3/4 · Specific individuals, Child safeguarding, Language & definitions
Accurately sexing trans-identified men who send misogynistic abuse to women is not discrimination. 'Man' is not a slur. I know a lot of you think the UN should intervene whenever women bruise your egos, but there is no human right to universal validation. https://t.co/xmQfeBEdlR
Classified critical · Intensity 3/4 · Language & definitions, Single-sex spaces, Free speech & cancellation
Replying to @OwenJonesStan
@OwenJonesStan @Naeluckmate @MinnOrchia India didn't become a woman. India is cosplaying a misogynistic male fantasy of what a woman is.
Classified hostile · Intensity 3/4 · Specific individuals, Sport, Language & definitions
Replying to @OwenJonesStan
@OwenJonesStan @MinnOrchia You've sent me the wrong video. There isn't a lady in this one, just a man revelling in his misogynistic performance of what he thinks 'woman' means: narcissistic, shallow and exhibitionist.
Classified hostile · Intensity 3/4 · Language & definitions, Specific individuals
@UKTruth_Seeker Believe it or not, I'm glad they're that naive. I don't want them to learn the way so many of us had to learn that single sex spaces are essential.
Classified critical · Intensity 1/4 · Single-sex spaces
@MinnOrchia Somebody really should have explained to you that your hurt feelings don't trump other people's rights, nor are women and girls validation props or comfort blankets.
Classified hostile · Intensity 3/4 · Single-sex spaces, Language & definitions
We don't leave our doors and windows wide open when we go out because 'thieves will find a way in, anyway.' Strangely, I've never heard anyone say 'let's stop background checking teachers, because paedophiles will always find a way to interfere with kids.' When men - all men, however they identify - are banned from women's spaces, those who disregard the ban can be challenged, inside the space and out. They mark themselves out as suspicious by breaking a rule decent men respect. Nobody claims the rule has successfully kept out every single man who wants to commit voyeurism or sexual assault. What we're saying is that allowing males into female only spaces on the basis of their claim to be a women removes an obstacle that has hitherto been *proven* to increase women and girls' safety. 88% of sexual crimes committed in changing/locker rooms happen in those that are unisex. Why? Because malign men don't have to justify their presence near unclothed women and girls. They can't be challenged. They don't stand out. This is obvious to all but the terminally naive. It is too seldom noted that every single man arguing for the removal of single sex spaces is arguing for his *own* right to enter those spaces. I know from experience that they feign outrage when this point is put to them, gibbering that they're just being good, virtuous progressives who're standing up for trans women, that they *personally* won't be availing themselves of the new opportunities afforded them. The fact remains that instead of calling out male violence against trans women, and working to make male spaces safer, these men have thrown their energy into the fight to remove women's and girls' rights to safety, privacy and dignity. And if anyone genuinely believes none of these enthusiastic heterosexual, non-trans-identified male 'allies' aren't personally enthralled by the idea of women and girls losing basic protections, I have several bridges to sell you.
Read the full postClassified hostile · Intensity 3/4 · Single-sex spaces, Child safeguarding, Language & definitions
For years now, women have been saying that self-ID will be exploited by predators and we’ve been told ‘no predator would bother to pretend to be a woman.’ Yet here we are - again. This paedophile didn’t receive the leniency he hoped for because he claimed to be a woman, but plenty have, including Katie Dolotowski, who, in a very similar case, filmed a 12-year-old in a bathroom cubicle and attempted to rape a 10-year-old in a women’s bathroom, and served his sentence in a women’s prison. The wilfully blind continue to insist that what is already happening couldn’t possibly happen. They wriggle like eels trying to find a loophole through which they can escape with their precious ideology intact. ‘He wasn’t really trans, though.’ ‘All groups have bad apples.’ ‘You can’t blame all trans people because some of them are rapists.’ So determined are you to cling to your absolutist slogans and your circular reasoning, you’re indifferent to the proven increased risk to women and girls. I watch you lying, equivocating and contorting yourself into knots trying to justify the unjustifiable, and I wonder when, if ever, shame will finally find you.
Read the full postClassified hostile · Intensity 3/4 · Single-sex spaces, Child safeguarding, Law & gender recognition
Replying to @tyrunn
@tyrunn @dmf500 @MikeWhitton @GettingEricD I'd advise you to do some research. There are proportionally more trans-identified men in jail for sexual crimes in the UK than there are in the male prison population as a whole. https://t.co/OmsbamrwuS
Classified hostile · Intensity 3/4 · Child safeguarding, Single-sex spaces, Specific individuals
Replying to @tyrunn
@tyrunn @dmf500 @MikeWhitton @GettingEricD Tell me, why does the argument 'it'll happen anyway, so why not make it easier?' never apply to trans-identified men? Why don't we hear 'they're going to get beaten up anyway, so let them use the gents?' Why is it only women who must accept the inevitability of rape and violence?
Classified critical · Intensity 3/4 · Single-sex spaces, Child safeguarding, Language & definitions
Replying to @tyrunn
@tyrunn @dmf500 @MikeWhitton @GettingEricD So you'd exclude trans women from changing and locker rooms ? Or are you comfortable holding open those doors for fellow men who identify as women, as well? You don't know how to identify those who might have malign intent, but women's safety must come second to male feelings.
Classified hostile · Intensity 3/4 · Single-sex spaces, Child safeguarding, Language & definitions
Replying to @tyrunn
@tyrunn @dmf500 @MikeWhitton @GettingEricD So what is the test for True Trans, which filter out men who want access to naked women or girls?
Classified critical · Intensity 3/4 · Single-sex spaces, Child safeguarding, Law & gender recognition
Replying to @tyrunn
@tyrunn @dmf500 @MikeWhitton @GettingEricD So saying 'I identify as a woman' is the mark of a true trans woman, but sometimes a man who isn't trans says 'I identify as a woman', and we can tell which is which by giving them both access to the women's changing rooms, and you see no flaws in this reasoning.
Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Single-sex spaces, Child safeguarding, Language & definitions
Replying to @jk_rowling
Telling women and girls they must accept increased risk to themselves to appease male feelings is the very definition of the patriarchy you claim to stand against. Vulnerable women are paying the price for a fashionable fallacy that has serious, real world consequences. 3/3
Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Single-sex spaces, Child safeguarding, Language & definitions
Replying to @jk_rowling
The statistics don't lie. Some - not all - trans-identified males have committed sexual and violent offences against women and girls. Some male predators have capitalised on gender identity activism to claim a trans identity they never espoused pre-conviction or assault. 2/3
Classified critical · Intensity 3/4 · Child safeguarding, Single-sex spaces, Specific individuals
It is possible to want trans people to be safe and happy while recognising that there are risks to women and girls in eradicating single sex spaces. Women and girls are being pressured to surrender their hard-won rights to a group that poses a proven danger to them. 1/3 https://t.co/MJGbUtgReP
Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Single-sex spaces, Child safeguarding
Replying to @Alyss_Turner
@Alyss_Turner @kostasth95 So women and girls have no right to privacy, dignity and safety. They are being unreasonably suspicious in not welcoming any male who says he's a female into spaces where they're wholly or partially unclothed. https://t.co/MtzGweq8fR
Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Single-sex spaces
Replying to @kostasth95
@kostasth95 88% of sex crimes in changing rooms and bathrooms happen in those that are mixed sex. There is no evidence to show that trans-identified men do not retain a male pattern of criminal offending.
Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Single-sex spaces, Child safeguarding
Replying to @kostasth95
@kostasth95 How do we safeguard women and children if the only way of weeding out ‘not really trans’ sex offenders is after they’ve committed crimes in single sex spaces?
Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Single-sex spaces, Child safeguarding
Replying to @GettingEricD
@GettingEricD The paedophile told police he identifies as a woman. You imply he’s not trans. How did you reach that decision?
Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Specific individuals, Language & definitions, Child safeguarding
That thing only evil, nasty bigots claim happens, and that never, ever happens, has happened. Again. https://t.co/MZ2NKoZ1O2
Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Child safeguarding, Single-sex spaces
@chris69403377 @1MikeFairclough What you're describing is what happens AFTER institutional capture. People take the path of least resistance - pretend not to see, as you put it - because they don't want to deal with the consequences of dissent. I have enormous sympathy for those who risk their livelihoods in speaking up, but none for those in positions of power who throw the most vulnerable under the bus, because it's easier/more lucrative to go with the flow.
Classified critical · Intensity 1/4 · Child safeguarding, Free speech & cancellation, Media & institutions
Replying to @1MikeFairclough
@1MikeFairclough Yes, because this is a top-down movement that relies on institutional capture rather than grassroots mobilisation. Bosses telling employees what to think/say, bullying/no-platforming of dissenters by cultural/academic elites, and the most vulnerable are paying the price.
Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Free speech & cancellation, Media & institutions, Child safeguarding
From recording murderers' and rapists' preferred gender identities rather than their sex, to accusing women who want basic safeguarding of having 'flawed unconscious bias', certain police forces are signalling loudly that vulnerable women deserve neither protection nor justice.
Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Child safeguarding, Single-sex spaces, Media & institutions, Language & definitions
Replying to @damekatydenise_
@damekatydenise_ @TheVikingDane 🤣I'm heartened to see trans animal activist Dr Dame Katy Denise exposed for the mendacious fraud she is. I encourage all #ChairPoverty donors to cancel their direct debits. The less well-heeled can protest by intentionally misgendering a gerbil or other small rodent.
Classified mocking · Intensity 3/4 · Specific individuals, Language & definitions
1. Crime statistics are rendered useless if violent and sexual attacks committed by men are recorded as female crimes. 2. Activists are already clamouring for this sadistic killer to be incarcerated in a women's prison. 3. Ideologically-driven misinformation is not journalism. https://t.co/9hnBBAY6eH
Classified critical · Intensity 3/4 · Single-sex spaces, Language & definitions, Media & institutions, Other
Every single word of this 👇
Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Media & institutions, Child safeguarding
I'm so sick of this shit. This is not a woman. These are #NotOurCrimes
Classified hostile · Intensity 3/4 · Language & definitions, Specific individuals
Replying to @bindelj
@bindelj We agreed we wouldn't make jokes about that flag any more, Julie. While I've learned and grown and educated myself, you clearly haven't. I'm not angry, just deeply disappointed.😔
Classified mocking · Intensity 1/4 · Language & definitions
Replying to @jk_rowling
Gutted I didn't have "knowing what a woman is is comparable to putting trans people in concentration camps" on today's Best Trans Activist Arguments bingo card. It's particularly galling, because I only needed "your books are shit" and I'd have won the big prize 😢 https://t.co/OGEZYOM2Ws
Classified mocking · Intensity 2/4 · Language & definitions, Free speech & cancellation
This is very sad news, but on the plus side, it proves some trans people have survived me knowing what a woman is, which you've previously assured me literally kills them. https://t.co/AFEODOH9Ep
Classified mocking · Intensity 3/4 · Language & definitions, Other
More than 70 per cent of transgender prisoners are in for sex offences or violent crimes. "The high levels of violent crimes among male prisoners who identify as women demonstrates why they should not be detained in female prisons" https://t.co/nSM3NliDrE
Classified critical · Intensity 3/4 · Single-sex spaces, Child safeguarding, Other
Replying to @sullyp40
@sullyp40 @PompeySteph 'That never happens' -> 'That hardly never happens' -> 'it happens but what about other bad stuff that happens' -> 'why are you obsessed with it happening' -> 'so what if it happens? It's not that serious.'
Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Child safeguarding, Single-sex spaces
@SexNotGI @ca_scrimshaw @Phoebe2403 @jojo731976 My resolve is strengthened daily, but it would take a heart of stone not to laugh at IW.
Classified mocking · Intensity 2/4 · Specific individuals, Media & institutions
Replying to @NoXYinXXprisons
@NoXYinXXprisons Solidarity, my friends xx
Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Single-sex spaces
The trans activist outrage that ensues on here whenever I share my belief that jailed women shouldn't be used as validation tools or emotional support props for trans-identified male sex offenders is as revealing as it's predictable. Such activists can't bring themselves to concede that a man who was convicted of harming women/girls ought not to be incarcerated with the demographic to whom he is a proven danger, because if they do, all their stock arguments ('no sexual predator would bother to pretend to be trans', 'no trans woman has ever harmed a woman in a women's only space', 'there is no danger in making all single sex spaces unisex') are exposed as the lies they are. If they admit that even a single man isn't a woman because he says he is, the entire edifice of gender identity ideology crumbles. This leaves activists who rely on bullying and slogans with nowhere to go but 'you hate all trans people', 'so you're saying all trans people are rapists' and, of course, 'you are causing a trans genocide.' I think this particular issue also causes conniptions because it threatens the activists' self image. These are people who preen themselves on their kindness and virtue, so acknowledging the truth - that they're indifferent to vulnerable women being assaulted or traumatised - threatens the idea they have of themselves. They therefore double down. The prisoners complaining aren't really afraid of rape or voyeurism or violence at all, they say. They're 'not exactly delicate flowers', as one self-identified empath put it. If you support putting violent and sexually predatory men into women's prisons, you are knowingly forcing those women to live in fear of, and, in some proven cases, to suffer abuse that many of them will have endured pre-incarceration. You are not kind. You are not righteous. Women have the basic human right not to suffer cruel and unusual punishment. #WomensRightsAreHumanRights
Read the full postClassified hostile · Intensity 3/4 · Single-sex spaces, Child safeguarding, Specific individuals, Law & gender recognition, Language & definitions
Replying to @jk_rowling
"Those male prisoners currently held alongside women include those convicted of murder and torture, and those with intact male genitalia..." Dr Kate Coleman on the new policy trampling over the rights of incarcerated women in Scotland. @NoXYinXXprisons https://t.co/LWfdVTy4Z3 2/2
Classified critical · Intensity 3/4 · Single-sex spaces, Child safeguarding, Law & gender recognition, Other
"...the aim is to increase the possibility for male prisoners who identify as transgender to have access to women in prison... This blatantly sees women as providing a service of “validation” and as objects... The policy is committed to secrecy." 1/2 https://t.co/LWfdVTy4Z3
Classified critical · Intensity 3/4 · Single-sex spaces, Child safeguarding, Law & gender recognition
Replying to @BettsCaro
@BettsCaro @HomoLittlest @FKASerioJosh @jonathanliew Plenty of leftist men's support was always tissue thin. They knew little about women's issues and cared less. Now they've got a shiny new ideology that enables them to feel good about themselves while dismissing and demeaning women. Win win.
Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Language & definitions, Free speech & cancellation, Other
@jonathanliew Your previous remarks leave no room for mystery about your own special interest in this subject. Like many ‘progressive’ misogynists, you seem delighted to have found an acceptable outlet for your disdain for women’s and girls’ sport. We see you, Jonathan. https://t.co/2H8IfuWDnH
Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Sport, Specific individuals
Replying to @Nerdlingen
@Nerdlingen @yourisolde If you look at the thread I've posted, you'll see the context. It's a 'trans zine' to which library users are directed in a display of 'trans joy'.
Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Media & institutions, Child safeguarding
Replying to @yourisolde
@yourisolde I'm asking why a *Women's Library* has chosen to display a comic which centres the desires of straight men, is focused on shaming lesbians for their sexual orientation and has a cover depicting a protected group dying out. This is not a feminist book, or one that deals with women's issues. It's a book telling lesbians they're wrong/bad for not having sex with the male-bodied.
Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Single-sex spaces, Language & definitions, Media & institutions
@atalanta44 I have read it. All of it. Lesbians are same-sex attracted women. Telling them they're terrible human/bigots/transphobes beings for not wanting sex with the penised is profoundly homophobic.
Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Single-sex spaces, Language & definitions, Specific individuals
Replying to @yourisolde
@yourisolde Given the ever-expanding definition of 'hate crime', which in Scotland has included taking a woman to court for tying suffragette ribbons on a tree, I think a library CHOOSING to display profoundly homophobic material in what appears to be a celebratory context is worth comment.
Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Media & institutions, Free speech & cancellation, Language & definitions
Replying to @IsleLesbos
@IsleLesbos I'm grateful for all the support I've received from my lesbian sisters xxx
Classified defensive · Intensity 0/4 · Specific individuals
Glasgow Women's Library has chosen to display a delightful penis-centred work (read the whole thread) designed to shame and coerce lesbians out of same-sex orientation. If anyone can think of a more appropriate name for the Glasgow Women's Library, do let me know.
Classified critical · Intensity 3/4 · Single-sex spaces, Language & definitions, Media & institutions
Female-only support services can be life saving for women who've suffered domestic abuse and sexual violence. This report exposes the current silencing of sector leaders and the dire consequences for victims.
Classified critical · Intensity 2/4 · Single-sex spaces, Child safeguarding, Law & gender recognition, Media & institutions
These are the posts classified trans-related. Search all 16,714 collected tweets, read the year-by-year analysis, or read the report on her campaign against trans rights.